GURUGRAM: The Haryana Real Estate Appellate Tribunal dismissed an Ashiana Dwellings appeal on Monday, November 16, 2026, after the promoter sought exemption from a required deposit of Rs 29,11,950. The dispute concerns homebuyers at Ashiana Mulberry Phase 1 in Sector 2, Sohna, Gurugram. The order was uploaded to the regulator's public judgments register on Tuesday, November 17.

The tribunal said the appeal could not be heard on its merits without the statutory pre-deposit. It rejected the waiver application and consequently dismissed the appeal. That outcome is a procedural decision about whether the promoter's appeal could be entertained, rather than a fresh determination of the parties' competing accounts of a settlement.

What the earlier direction required

The appeal challenged an August 14, 2026 order of the Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority, Gurugram. The November tribunal order reproduces the operative directions, which required the promoter to pay delayed possession charges at an annual interest rate of 10.80% on the amount paid by the complainants.

The reproduced direction starts the relevant delay period on July 27, 2019, the stated due date of possession, and runs it until the offer of possession plus two months. It refers to the proviso to Section 18(1) of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act and Rule 15 of the Haryana rules. The tribunal's account does not supply an offer date from which readers could independently calculate a final period.

The authority had also required arrears of interest accrued until then to be paid within 90 days of its order, citing Rule 16(2). It directed the complainants to pay any outstanding dues after adjustment of interest for the delayed period. These were reciprocal accounting directions in the earlier order, not a declaration that no balance could remain payable by the buyers.

A further direction set the rate chargeable to an allottee in default at the same prescribed annual rate of 10.80% applicable to the promoter's delay liability. The reproduced operative portion also said the decision would apply, with the necessary adaptations, to cases identified in paragraph 3 of the authority's order. The appellate decision does not reproduce that full case table.

Why the appeal stopped at the deposit stage

Ashiana Dwellings accompanied its appeal with an application seeking waiver or exemption under Section 43(5). Its counsel argued that the delayed possession claim had already been settled, that agreed compensation had been paid or adjusted, and that possession had been handed over. Counsel also argued that the authority had not appreciated the settlement's binding effect.

Those statements are the promoter's submissions recorded in the official tribunal order. They should not be presented as findings that the buyers had accepted a final settlement or that the underlying liability had disappeared. The tribunal dealt with the absence of the deposit before it could examine the appeal's merits.

The registry reported that the required deposit was Rs 29,11,950. The tribunal said this had been calculated in relation to the delayed possession charges and interest in the challenged order. The amount is therefore the pre-deposit recorded for this appeal. It is not described as a new penalty imposed by the tribunal on November 16.

  • Appeal: 1006 of 2026.
  • Waiver application: CM 9384 of 2026.
  • Tribunal decision: November 16, 2026.
  • Public upload: November 17, 2026.
  • Required pre-deposit: Rs 29,11,950.
  • Result: waiver application and appeal dismissed.

Chairman Justice Rajan Gupta and technical member Dinesh Singh Chauhan heard the matter. Their reasoning relied on the Supreme Court's Newtech Promoters and Developers decision and referred to a similar view in the Parthivi Construction matter decided on September 22, 2026. The tribunal concluded that the applicable law left no provision for waiving or exempting the required deposit.

The Newtech passage reproduced in the decision distinguishes appeals against penalties from orders involving money payable to an allottee. For a penalty, it describes a deposit of at least 30% or a higher amount directed by the tribunal. For the other category, it describes depositing the total payable to the allottee, including interest and compensation where applicable. That distinction explains why a deposit requirement cannot be reduced to a single percentage for every promoter appeal.

What the published outcome establishes

The order directs that copies be sent to the parties or their counsel and to the authority, and that the file be consigned to the records. It does not record payment to the buyers following dismissal, a subsequent challenge or a revised possession date. Any later development would need a separate verified document.

For other Gurugram property proceedings, readers can refer to the separate Sector 65 compensation order, the revised November 19 hearing list and the Greater SPR land award report. None concerns this Ashiana Mulberry appeal.