Aave Labs has asked the Financial Conduct Authority to reconcile proposals for decentralised finance, arguing that measures protecting users could expose developers and interfaces to regulation. Its response dated 18 November challenges how the regulator would distinguish technical support from intermediation, rather than announcing any change to law.

The company wants scam blocking, sanctions screening and bounded emergency controls assessed differently from discretionary management of customers’ transactions. It argues that building, maintaining or helping govern a protocol should not, by itself, establish that a person conducts a regulated activity. These are recommendations from an industry participant, not conclusions accepted by the FCA.

Aave also seeks a workable route for authorised firms to offer access to DeFi. It warns that execution and asset admission requirements could together operate as a practical prohibition. That claim needs qualification: the underlying rules distinguish between client categories and contain exceptions, while the perimeter draft already recognises that some protective controls need not amount to intermediation.

Where technical access meets regulated activity

The proposed perimeter guidance, CP26/36, expressly says restrictions imposed for technical security or legal compliance do not necessarily constitute substantive intermediation. Transaction-linked fees are not decisive either. Those qualifications matter when assessing the response: the FCA has not proposed a categorical rule that every security check makes a software provider a regulated intermediary.

However, the draft also says an absence of discretion does not automatically make a service purely technical. A provider can participate substantively through automated functions. Its assessment turns on what the service actually does, not whether its operator labels it software, technology or DeFi. Additional useful features and commercial remuneration do not automatically disqualify a service.

Another limit concerns who can use the technical-services exclusion: the provider must be neither an authorised person nor a payment service provider. Consequently, the exclusion is not a universal route for regulated businesses seeking protocol access. These proposed boundaries extend the questions described in Dalimss News’ earlier report on the FCA consultations.

The other paper, GC26/7, addresses a different question: how firms already subject to operational resilience and financial crime requirements should manage DeFi exposure. It proposes guidance on existing obligations, rather than a new DeFi-specific rulebook. Its stated objective is comparable regulatory outcomes when firms use decentralised technology instead of conventional financial infrastructure.

That entails identifying dependencies beyond the customer-facing interface. The FCA describes mapping smart contracts, external protocols, price feeds, bridges and supporting technology, alongside incident response and key management. Firms should also identify governance arrangements for upgrades and emergency controls. Those operational dependencies explain why protocol maintenance and governance remain relevant even when customers control their own assets.

The draft also envisages testing severe but plausible disruptions, including infrastructure failures and unavailable third-party services. Outsourcing tests does not transfer responsibility for their quality. Firms must review their arrangements after significant operational changes. Both consultations set 18 November as the response deadline. GC26/7 says the FCA plans final guidance in the first quarter of 2027, leaving the response as input to an unfinished process.

Access restrictions have defined limits

The regulated-access concern must also be read against the FCA’s June policy statement and made rules. Execution-venue requirements cover retail and elective professional clients, excluding defined overseas categories. Executed orders must use a UK qualifying cryptoasset execution venue; other arranging activity carries a requirement to take all reasonable steps towards that outcome.

Separate retail admission rules generally connect access to admission on a UK platform and accompanying disclosures. They include an exception for UK qualifying stablecoins and permit certain exits after an asset is withdrawn from trading. The policy statement also explains that principal dealers may hedge their own positions through non-UK liquidity. It is not an unrestricted domestic-only trading mandate.

These provisions belong to the framework scheduled to operate from 25 October 2027, not a restriction newly imposed this November. Alongside the separate parliamentary work on UK crypto legislation, the relevant distinction is between rules already made for future operation and guidance not yet finalised. Whether the FCA changes that guidance in response remains unresolved.