The Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association has called for clearer investor protections when stocks trade directly on blockchain-based venues. In a November 18 analysis, the association, known as SIFMA, said potential benefits such as extended trading and rapid settlement come with responsibilities and protection differences that buyers should understand.

The intervention follows a letter from four US senators questioning the Securities and Exchange Commission’s existing framework. Published by Senator Angela Alsobrooks’s office on November 16, the letter itself is dated November 13. Alsobrooks, Catherine Cortez Masto, Mark Warner and Ruben Gallego asked SEC Chairman Paul Atkins for answers within 30 days and sought a transparent rulemaking process.

The lawmakers focused on financial-crime controls, public companies’ ability to object to tokenization, and safeguards for investors trading without a broker. They questioned who bears responsibility when a token moves from a verified participant to an unverified wallet, and how custody and backing would be assured. Those are requests for clarification, not findings of misconduct by a particular venue.

What the SEC order actually permits

The underlying policy is not a new November authorization. The SEC’s September 17 order grants temporary, conditional exemptions from the legal definition of an exchange to qualifying tokenized-securities venues and from the definition of a dealer to certain liquidity providers. It covers permissioned trading through automated market makers and liquidity pools. The exemptions run until September 17, 2031, although the commission can modify them.

The order does not remove tokenized stocks from securities law altogether. Applicable anti-fraud and anti-manipulation provisions continue to apply. It also excludes tokens that merely provide synthetic exposure to an underlying security. No primary issuance or initial securities offering is permitted on a venue under this exemption.

A venue must verify that an eligible token provides the rights and privileges of the equivalent traditional share. These include dividends, voting rights and an interest in residual assets on liquidation. That requirement concerns the security’s underlying rights; it should not be confused with a promise that every trading arrangement carries identical protections.

Investor protections and issuer objections

SIFMA’s comparison, written by Peter J. Ryan and Micah Smith, argues that direct venue trading differs from using a broker in areas including best execution, Securities Investor Protection Corporation coverage and FINRA arbitration. The association also highlights the work of securing a digital wallet and converting between dollars and digital assets. This is an industry association’s assessment, rather than a new SEC ruling. SIFMA urges the commission to clarify baseline protections and pursue notice-and-comment rulemaking, rather than leaving those questions to individual venues.

The senators separately questioned whether issuers can make standing objections or withdraw consent after the initial window. Their letter says more than 60 companies had objected, a count attributed to the lawmakers rather than independently established here. They also asked how smaller issuers would manage repeated notices from different venues.

Existing SEC staff guidance explains part of the notification process. Its October 20 FAQ, updated October 21, says a venue must publish an accurate, complete notice at least 30 calendar days before operating and keep its disclosures current. A notice can identify stocks whose issuer-objection periods are still pending. If an issuer objects within the required period, the venue must reflect that objection and cannot make the stock available for trading.

Those FAQs explicitly represent staff views, not a commission rule or legally binding amendment. They explain procedures within the existing framework; they should not be presented as a new response to the senators’ letter.

The SEC also maintains a public list of prospective venues that have submitted notices of intent. The opened list names TSV LLC, OKXICE TSV, Kephas Corporation doing business as Perpetuals.com, and Formation Securities LLC. Listing does not establish that a firm satisfies the exemption’s conditions, and staff do not validate the merits or accuracy of its notice. A notice of intent therefore is not an SEC endorsement or proof that trading has begun.

Related coverage distinguishes UK parliamentary approval of crypto amendments from operative rules, and examines Moscow Exchange’s crypto participation requirements. Neither development changes the scope of this US exemption.