An adviser to the European Union’s top court has backed checks on crypto businesses’ internal organisation before registration under the former anti-money-laundering framework. Advocate General Jean Richard de la Tour’s November 19 opinion in case C-415/25 is nonbinding and does not settle the underlying dispute over Dutch supervisory charges.
He proposes allowing authorities to request information demonstrating sound and controlled management, and to refuse registration when that information is incomplete or inaccurate. National judges must still examine proportionality, legality, legal certainty and nondiscrimination. The opinion expressly leaves the disputed ongoing supervision fees and their possible disproportionality outside the question referred.
Registration costs are not one single dispute
The distinction matters because the Dutch litigation contains separate disputes over registration checks and who must pay for them. In its June 24, 2025 decision, the College van Beroep voor het bedrijfsleven found that budgeted registration-processing costs had improperly been included in the same year’s ongoing supervision tariffs. Registration was a one-off action chargeable to its recipient.
The judgment identified €300,000 of those budgeted costs in the 2020 tariff and €100,000 in the 2021 tariff. A different €200,000 concerned an actual registration-cost overrun from 2020 carried into 2021. These are not interchangeable amounts: the latter connects the later-year litigation to the EU-law dispute over how demanding the original registration process could be.
The Dutch court ordered DNB to take new decisions on the 2020 objections within thirty weeks, ending those proceedings. It suspended the 2021 proceedings pending an EU interpretation of the registration obligation. Its public explanation says those proceedings will resume after the Court’s answer. An advocate general’s recommendation is not that final answer or validation of the disputed charges.
DNB’s own 2020 accountability report provides the operational background. Crypto exchange services involving official currencies and custodial wallet providers entered the Dutch anti-money-laundering and sanctions supervision framework on May 21, 2020. Existing businesses wishing to continue had to submit registration requests by that date and be registered by November 21. The report describes application assessment as the principal activity that year.
The regulator reported forty-eight requests by May 21 and ten more afterwards. At the end of December, fifteen businesses were registered and sixteen applications remained under consideration. It said some applicants withdrew, while cases showing a concrete prospect of prompt completion continued beyond November 21. Those figures describe the system’s launch, not the size of today’s licensed crypto market.
The report put actual crypto supervision expenditure at €1.9 million against a €1.7 million budget. DNB attributed the overrun chiefly to more intensive registration assessments and additional processing time, saying applications needed repeated adjustments. This is the regulator’s historical explanation of expenditure, not a judicial finding that every cost could lawfully be recovered from the sector.
Why registration differs from payment licensing
The broader registration-versus-licensing argument has a specific legislative history. The Commission’s July 2016 impact assessment compared bringing exchanges under anti-money-laundering rules with regulating them under the revised Payment Services Directive. The latter option would have added licensing, minimum capital, safeguarding and consumer protection requirements, rather than simply requiring firms to identify customers and report suspicious transactions.
That assessment described customer checks as covering identity verification, beneficial ownership, the purpose of business relationships and ongoing scrutiny of transactions. It also considered custodial wallets separately because users could transfer virtual currencies without necessarily converting back into conventional money through an exchange. The design question was therefore which intermediaries could supply information for financial-crime controls.
The document recorded support from twenty-seven member states for the anti-money-laundering approach, with one preferring the payments-law option. Most opposed the broader route partly because they feared it would lend virtual currencies excessive legitimacy and encourage consumers to regard them as safe. These were the policy choices examined in 2016, not a new assessment of crypto products issued this week.
The advocate general treats that history as compatible with preventive registration checks, not a requirement for purely clerical enrolment. He separately notes the later MiCA authorisation framework. The opinion concerns the earlier regime, rather than a new licence or permission for providers operating today.
Related coverage: BaFin crypto fund custody guidance and French Senate crypto seizure bill.









